R5 P14 QB Joe Flacco, BAL (8)
R8 P1 QB Brett Favre, MIN (4)
R13 P14 QB Matt Cassel, KC (4)
R1 P1 RB Chris Johnson, TEN (9)
R2 P14 RB Pierre Thomas, NO (10)
R9 P14 RB Kevin Smith, DET (7)
R15 P14 RB Jason Snelling, ATL (8)
R16 P1 RB Jerious Norwood, ATL (8)
R3 P14 WR Mike Sims-Walker, JAX (9)
R4 P1 WR Dwayne Bowe, KC (4)
R6 P1 WR Hines Ward, PIT (5)
R7 P14 WR Jerricho Cotchery, NYJ (7)
R11 P14 WR Anthony Gonzalez, IND (7)
R18 P1 WR Jordan Shipley, CIN (6)
R19 P14 WR Maurice Stovall, TB (4)
R10 P1 TE Dustin Keller, NYJ (7)
R12 P1 TE Greg Olsen, CHI (8)
R14 P1 DEF Philadelphia Eagles, PHI (8)
R17 P14 K Lawrence Tynes, NYG (8)
Appreciate feedback. Weak at RB after my starters, excited about my recievers I believe they will have great years!
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
Originally posted by Surgically Enhanced TD's:
R5 P14 QB Joe Flacco, BAL (8)
R8 P1 QB Brett Favre, MIN (4)
R13 P14 QB Matt Cassel, KC (4)
R1 P1 RB Chris Johnson, TEN (9)
R2 P14 RB Pierre Thomas, NO (10)
R9 P14 RB Kevin Smith, DET (7)
R15 P14 RB Jason Snelling, ATL (8)
R16 P1 RB Jerious Norwood, ATL (8)
R3 P14 WR Mike Sims-Walker, JAX (9)
R4 P1 WR Dwayne Bowe, KC (4)
R6 P1 WR Hines Ward, PIT (5)
R7 P14 WR Jerricho Cotchery, NYJ (7)
R11 P14 WR Anthony Gonzalez, IND (7)
R18 P1 WR Jordan Shipley, CIN (6)
R19 P14 WR Maurice Stovall, TB (4)
R10 P1 TE Dustin Keller, NYJ (7)
R12 P1 TE Greg Olsen, CHI (8)
R14 P1 DEF Philadelphia Eagles, PHI (8)
R17 P14 K Lawrence Tynes, NYG (8)
Appreciate feedback. Weak at RB after my starters, excited about my recievers I believe they will have great years! wow, i hate to be bearer of bad news but those wr's have lots of question marks.. walker= needs to show consistency. ward= old and no qb, bowe== just fat and inconsistent, cotchery= the no. 3 receiver now with edwards and holmes i'd actually put him as 4th option on that squad because keller will get lots of looks, the rest of your wr's core are just plain awful. sorry, just an opinion.. like your 2 starting rb's alot.. qb is ok, te good, wr's will kill you here.
R5 P14 QB Joe Flacco, BAL (8)
R8 P1 QB Brett Favre, MIN (4)
R13 P14 QB Matt Cassel, KC (4)
R1 P1 RB Chris Johnson, TEN (9)
R2 P14 RB Pierre Thomas, NO (10)
R9 P14 RB Kevin Smith, DET (7)
R15 P14 RB Jason Snelling, ATL (8)
R16 P1 RB Jerious Norwood, ATL (8)
R3 P14 WR Mike Sims-Walker, JAX (9)
R4 P1 WR Dwayne Bowe, KC (4)
R6 P1 WR Hines Ward, PIT (5)
R7 P14 WR Jerricho Cotchery, NYJ (7)
R11 P14 WR Anthony Gonzalez, IND (7)
R18 P1 WR Jordan Shipley, CIN (6)
R19 P14 WR Maurice Stovall, TB (4)
R10 P1 TE Dustin Keller, NYJ (7)
R12 P1 TE Greg Olsen, CHI (8)
R14 P1 DEF Philadelphia Eagles, PHI (8)
R17 P14 K Lawrence Tynes, NYG (8)
Appreciate feedback. Weak at RB after my starters, excited about my recievers I believe they will have great years! wow, i hate to be bearer of bad news but those wr's have lots of question marks.. walker= needs to show consistency. ward= old and no qb, bowe== just fat and inconsistent, cotchery= the no. 3 receiver now with edwards and holmes i'd actually put him as 4th option on that squad because keller will get lots of looks, the rest of your wr's core are just plain awful. sorry, just an opinion.. like your 2 starting rb's alot.. qb is ok, te good, wr's will kill you here.
-
boutrous11
- Posts: 1573
- Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 6:00 pm
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
don't listen to weber. your receivers are average at worst. solid team imo.
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
Surgically Enhanced,
I actually like your WR's. I think that MSW is a huge upside guy this year, Bowe should get back to where he was 2 years ago, and I'm always surprised that people sleep on Hines Ward almost every year. I'm not so sure about your depth at WR but the first 3-4 should be solid.
Wayne
I actually like your WR's. I think that MSW is a huge upside guy this year, Bowe should get back to where he was 2 years ago, and I'm always surprised that people sleep on Hines Ward almost every year. I'm not so sure about your depth at WR but the first 3-4 should be solid.
Wayne
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
colts, but every one of them is a question mark, i at least one one solid low risk player at every spot.. and there are no low risk wr's in the bunch.. you have to agree wth that.. sure there is upside with simms and bowe, but i just think bowe will end up being 3rd or 4th option on that team.. they are going to get back to what they do best and thats run ball....
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
Originally posted by BillyWaz:
From the 7 hole....
QB- Jay Cutler
QB- Matthew Stafford
RB- Frank Gore
RB- Joseph Addai
RB- Montario Hardesty
RB- Mewelde Moore
RB- Sammy Morris
WR- Vincent Jackson
WR- Sidney Rice
WR- Julian Edelman
WR- Arrelious Benn
WR- Jabar Gaffney
WR- James Jones
WR- Brandon LaFell
WR- Legedu Naanee
TE- Zach Miller
TE- Ben Watson
K- Mason Crosby
D- NY Jets
Had a lot of guys missing on my sheet, but it is a May draft, and it is always fun to draft a team!
Good luck everyone! billy yu know i had to critique your team.. so here it goes..
i like your qb's.. im a martz fan.. i think cutler will have huge year.
rb's.. gore love, addai and the rest of the crew.. question marks but you can survive with the ones you have.
wr's .. just not a fan of jackson but he is solid.. rice if farve, good , edelman, maybe a good pick first few weeks, but once welker comes back, he'll take a back seat.. the rest of the wr's are all fill in's and maybe you'll get one who comes through as a good wr 3 or maybe wr2 (j. jones. = like him). driver is getting old.
TE's. like miller.. would of liked to see you get a better starting WR as the WR1. i think you'll be chasing wr's all year but from what i've seen with the other teams i see nobody that really did that well .. i'll give you a C+ or B-
From the 7 hole....
QB- Jay Cutler
QB- Matthew Stafford
RB- Frank Gore
RB- Joseph Addai
RB- Montario Hardesty
RB- Mewelde Moore
RB- Sammy Morris
WR- Vincent Jackson
WR- Sidney Rice
WR- Julian Edelman
WR- Arrelious Benn
WR- Jabar Gaffney
WR- James Jones
WR- Brandon LaFell
WR- Legedu Naanee
TE- Zach Miller
TE- Ben Watson
K- Mason Crosby
D- NY Jets
Had a lot of guys missing on my sheet, but it is a May draft, and it is always fun to draft a team!
Good luck everyone! billy yu know i had to critique your team.. so here it goes..
i like your qb's.. im a martz fan.. i think cutler will have huge year.
rb's.. gore love, addai and the rest of the crew.. question marks but you can survive with the ones you have.
wr's .. just not a fan of jackson but he is solid.. rice if farve, good , edelman, maybe a good pick first few weeks, but once welker comes back, he'll take a back seat.. the rest of the wr's are all fill in's and maybe you'll get one who comes through as a good wr 3 or maybe wr2 (j. jones. = like him). driver is getting old.
TE's. like miller.. would of liked to see you get a better starting WR as the WR1. i think you'll be chasing wr's all year but from what i've seen with the other teams i see nobody that really did that well .. i'll give you a C+ or B-
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
Originally posted by Rob B:
Fun draft,
From the 2 hole:
QB Matt Ryan 8 ATL R8 P2
QB Alex Smith 9 SF R13 P13
RB Adrian Peterson 4 MIN R1 P2
RB Ryan Mathews 10 SD R2 P13
RB Michael Bush 10 OAK R9 P13
RB Toby Gerhart 4 MIN R11 P13
RB Javon Ringer 9 TEN R12 P2
RB Bernard Scott 6 CIN R16 P2
WR Mike Wallace 5 PIT R4 P2
WR Jeremy Maclin 8 PHI R5 P13
WR Santonio Holmes 7 NYJ R6 P2
WR Devin Hester 8 CHI R7 P13
WR Lee Evans 6 BUF R10 P2
WR Mike Williams 4 TB R15 P13
WR Kenneth Moore 6 CAR R19 P13
TE Dallas Clark 7 IND R3 P13
TE Jared Cook 9 TEN R18 P2
K Robbie Gould 8 CHI R17 P13
DEF New Orleans Saints 10 NO R14 P2 Rob by far i like your team the best.. i give you B+ or A-.
Qb's serviceable.
RB's. 2 good starters and if Bush starts then u did great.
WR's. this is your strength.. you don't have 5 good wr's. all who will play alot, no true no. 1 but i don't think you need it when playing in the same league as BIlly and that squad he put together..LOL..
TE's. Awesome.. love him
Very good draft.. i predict unless you have major injury to AP, you will easily win this league..
Fun draft,
From the 2 hole:
QB Matt Ryan 8 ATL R8 P2
QB Alex Smith 9 SF R13 P13
RB Adrian Peterson 4 MIN R1 P2
RB Ryan Mathews 10 SD R2 P13
RB Michael Bush 10 OAK R9 P13
RB Toby Gerhart 4 MIN R11 P13
RB Javon Ringer 9 TEN R12 P2
RB Bernard Scott 6 CIN R16 P2
WR Mike Wallace 5 PIT R4 P2
WR Jeremy Maclin 8 PHI R5 P13
WR Santonio Holmes 7 NYJ R6 P2
WR Devin Hester 8 CHI R7 P13
WR Lee Evans 6 BUF R10 P2
WR Mike Williams 4 TB R15 P13
WR Kenneth Moore 6 CAR R19 P13
TE Dallas Clark 7 IND R3 P13
TE Jared Cook 9 TEN R18 P2
K Robbie Gould 8 CHI R17 P13
DEF New Orleans Saints 10 NO R14 P2 Rob by far i like your team the best.. i give you B+ or A-.
Qb's serviceable.
RB's. 2 good starters and if Bush starts then u did great.
WR's. this is your strength.. you don't have 5 good wr's. all who will play alot, no true no. 1 but i don't think you need it when playing in the same league as BIlly and that squad he put together..LOL..
TE's. Awesome.. love him
Very good draft.. i predict unless you have major injury to AP, you will easily win this league..
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
Originally posted by weber:
colts, but every one of them is a question mark, i at least one one solid low risk player at every spot.. and there are no low risk wr's in the bunch.. you have to agree wth that.. sure there is upside with simms and bowe, but i just think bowe will end up being 3rd or 4th option on that team.. they are going to get back to what they do best and thats run ball.... No doubt they are question marks! But I do like the upside and the value. I'm not saying it's my favorite team by any means but it definitely has the firepower to compete if Bowe and MSW can step up this year.
Wayne
colts, but every one of them is a question mark, i at least one one solid low risk player at every spot.. and there are no low risk wr's in the bunch.. you have to agree wth that.. sure there is upside with simms and bowe, but i just think bowe will end up being 3rd or 4th option on that team.. they are going to get back to what they do best and thats run ball.... No doubt they are question marks! But I do like the upside and the value. I'm not saying it's my favorite team by any means but it definitely has the firepower to compete if Bowe and MSW can step up this year.
Wayne
Second Magazine NFFC Draft
Originally posted by weber:
quote:Originally posted by BillyWaz:
From the 7 hole....
QB- Jay Cutler
QB- Matthew Stafford
RB- Frank Gore
RB- Joseph Addai
RB- Montario Hardesty
RB- Mewelde Moore
RB- Sammy Morris
WR- Vincent Jackson
WR- Sidney Rice
WR- Julian Edelman
WR- Arrelious Benn
WR- Jabar Gaffney
WR- James Jones
WR- Brandon LaFell
WR- Legedu Naanee
TE- Zach Miller
TE- Ben Watson
K- Mason Crosby
D- NY Jets
Had a lot of guys missing on my sheet, but it is a May draft, and it is always fun to draft a team!
Good luck everyone! billy yu know i had to critique your team.. so here it goes..
i like your qb's.. im a martz fan.. i think cutler will have huge year.
rb's.. gore love, addai and the rest of the crew.. question marks but you can survive with the ones you have.
wr's .. just not a fan of jackson but he is solid.. rice if farve, good , edelman, maybe a good pick first few weeks, but once welker comes back, he'll take a back seat.. the rest of the wr's are all fill in's and maybe you'll get one who comes through as a good wr 3 or maybe wr2 (j. jones. = like him). driver is getting old.
TE's. like miller.. would of liked to see you get a better starting WR as the WR1. i think you'll be chasing wr's all year but from what i've seen with the other teams i see nobody that really did that well .. i'll give you a C+ or B- [/QUOTE]I appreciate the critique, Mike.
Honestly, when you are picking in the middle and Gore is there at 7, you take him. Just curious as to what WR you thought I could get in the 2nd round that is better than V-Jax?
I made some mistakes in this draft, but I can easily live with this team. Not with my team, but some of your WR critiques of other teams are really "off" IMO.
I bet you thought Ward was old last year, too?
quote:Originally posted by BillyWaz:
From the 7 hole....
QB- Jay Cutler
QB- Matthew Stafford
RB- Frank Gore
RB- Joseph Addai
RB- Montario Hardesty
RB- Mewelde Moore
RB- Sammy Morris
WR- Vincent Jackson
WR- Sidney Rice
WR- Julian Edelman
WR- Arrelious Benn
WR- Jabar Gaffney
WR- James Jones
WR- Brandon LaFell
WR- Legedu Naanee
TE- Zach Miller
TE- Ben Watson
K- Mason Crosby
D- NY Jets
Had a lot of guys missing on my sheet, but it is a May draft, and it is always fun to draft a team!
Good luck everyone! billy yu know i had to critique your team.. so here it goes..
i like your qb's.. im a martz fan.. i think cutler will have huge year.
rb's.. gore love, addai and the rest of the crew.. question marks but you can survive with the ones you have.
wr's .. just not a fan of jackson but he is solid.. rice if farve, good , edelman, maybe a good pick first few weeks, but once welker comes back, he'll take a back seat.. the rest of the wr's are all fill in's and maybe you'll get one who comes through as a good wr 3 or maybe wr2 (j. jones. = like him). driver is getting old.
TE's. like miller.. would of liked to see you get a better starting WR as the WR1. i think you'll be chasing wr's all year but from what i've seen with the other teams i see nobody that really did that well .. i'll give you a C+ or B- [/QUOTE]I appreciate the critique, Mike.
Honestly, when you are picking in the middle and Gore is there at 7, you take him. Just curious as to what WR you thought I could get in the 2nd round that is better than V-Jax?
I made some mistakes in this draft, but I can easily live with this team. Not with my team, but some of your WR critiques of other teams are really "off" IMO.
I bet you thought Ward was old last year, too?