Top 15 QBs From Fantasy Sports Magazine

[Diesel]

Originally posted by Just Russ:
Tom, great list! Not the order that I would put them, but a terrific effort nonetheless. How'd I do giving props Marc? Russ, your props are the best. You know I was just busting chops before.

[pizzatyme]

Originally posted by Diesel Inc.:
quote:Originally posted by Just Russ:
Tom, great list! Not the order that I would put them, but a terrific effort nonetheless. How'd I do giving props Marc? Russ, your props are the best. You know I was just busting chops before. [/QUOTE]

[pizzatyme]

Ok, my totally unscientific top 10 and 5 honorable mentions:

Brady- if healthy, why not a return to top slot?
Brees
Rodgers- weapons, confidence

Manning
McNabulous- could be #2 with his upside


Warner-will likely be overdrafted and has high downside. Boldin leaving drops him considerably.
Hasselbeck- healthy targets


Culpepper- yep, I said it
Ryan


Schaub


Honorable mention:
Cutler
Flacco
Delhomme
Rivers
Vikings QB

Your thoughts? Please, only positive feel-good responses.

[pizzatyme]

Originally posted by GK:
]...Rivers is ready to build on his last two years which were not too shabby, thank you...he'll most likely be throwing more and SNAKE can't possibly see him being left out of the top 5 but you have left him out of the top 10 here - what gives?...btw Comrade Russ - nice list here...SNAKE I think the Bolts have a 3 headed rushing attack and a weak division. That to me, smells like blowouts and no need to pass.

I wouldn't take him unless it were a DC. I could see him having big weeks when needed, but too up and down. This in no way means I don't like his abilities, just his situation.

[mikeybok]

Originally posted by Just Russ:

Honorable mention:

Vikings QB

Your thoughts? Please, only positive feel-good responses. I think you rated Favre a little low ... but I thought you made nice use of capitalization in your post.

[pizzatyme]

Originally posted by Ugly Yellow Tomatoes:
quote:Originally posted by Just Russ:

Honorable mention:

Vikings QB

Your thoughts? Please, only positive feel-good responses. I think you rated Favre a little low ... but I thought you made nice use of capitalization in your post. [/QUOTE]Now that's what I'm talking about!

[Greg Ambrosius]

I like the banter all and the different opinions on this position is just the start of a wild off-season. Tom will post each of the other positions this week – likely one every other day – to get the football talk going on our boards. We're just wrapping up our first football issue and will start to lead the discussions on these boards starting this week.

The three drafts we conducted for the magazine really opened our eyes to this year's drafts. I wrote in my editorial that in 20 years of posting rankings for Fantasy Sports Magazine, I can never remember a year that was so wide open for football. I mean right from the first pick, everyone will have a different opinion of the rankings. This year is WIDE OPEN for anyone to win.

So get your butts back on the Message Boards and get ready to talk some draft strategy and rankings. This should be fun and I'll dive in right after the magazine goes to press. Should be a fun off-season of football banter.

[Greg Ambrosius]

Okay, Tom listed our Top 15 for the magazine. Here's where each of those quarterbacks went in our three magazine drafts among QBs:

Here are the quarterbacks:
1. Drew Brees: 1, 1, 1
2. Peyton Manning: 2, 3, 3
3. Tom Brady: 4, 2, 2
4. Aaron Rodgers: 5, 7, 6
5. Kurt Warner: 3, 4, 8
6. Philip Rivers: 6, 5, 4
7. Tony Romo: 7, 6, 5
8. Donovan McNabb: 9, 8, 7
9. Jay Cutler: 8, 9, 9
10. Matt Ryan: 11, 10, 12
11. Matt Schaub: 13, 11, 10
12. Carson Palmer: 10, 12, 13
13. Ben Roethlisberger: 12, 13, 11
14. Matt Cassel: 14, 14, 15
15. Matt Hasselbeck: 16, 16, 18

Thoughts?