Page 1 of 4

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 4:13 pm
by Route Collectors
I thought we should have a thread to discuss each round...the good/bad and so on.

1) How do 4 top RB's all go for $55 or under? 1 for under $50. I'm happy to have gotten 2 of them.

2) A little pricey....Brees $40...OK for regular auction but too rich for a DC IMO

3) What gives on the Kickers? $5, $5, $6 :eek:

4) Breaston $17, Caldwell $5....a lot of early speculation in these bids. Personally I think these bids are OK but didn't expect to see them this high so early in the draft.

5) Balt $8, Chi. $7.......it's true defense wins championships...just not in DC's...at least not just one defense.

Imagine if these prices held true throughout and you wanted 3 D's and 3 K's...you would spend 36-42 just at those spots. :eek:

Anyway...that was a fun round and it's waaaaaay too early to throw darts. Just a few observations to pass the time. ;)

[ February 22, 2009, 10:16 PM: Message edited by: Route C ]

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 2:49 am
by bald is beautiful
I was surprised at the prices that those RB's ended at. You got two good RB bargains. Great way to start for you. All week I expected that I would to go and get MJD, but that changed Sunday afternoon when I decided to go get both AZ WR's, because I think Boldin will not stay.

I would not normally spend $17 to get Breaston, but to pair him with Fitz I was willing to do that. If I'm right, my production from those two spots will be really good. If I'm wrong, it's only a $125 auction.

You are right - big $ being spent on K's and defenses.

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 8:34 am
by boutrous11
well, last year i got stuck with 2 crappy kickers and 2 crappy defenses. and i had to pay too much for them, as there were several of us scrambling to get them at the end of the draft. wasn't going to let that happen again. :D

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 8:55 am
by Route Collectors
Originally posted by boutrous11:
well, last year i got stuck with 2 crappy kickers and 2 crappy defenses. and i had to pay too much for them, as there were several of us scrambling to get them at the end of the draft. wasn't going to let that happen again. :D That's an excellent point. The better prices are usually toward the middle of the draft.

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:54 am
by bobsgym13
Originally posted by Route C:
quote:Originally posted by boutrous11:
well, last year i got stuck with 2 crappy kickers and 2 crappy defenses. and i had to pay too much for them, as there were several of us scrambling to get them at the end of the draft. wasn't going to let that happen again. :D That's an excellent point. The better prices are usually toward the middle of the draft. [/QUOTE]Prediction - No DEF under $4

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:00 am
by bald is beautiful
Originally posted by Bob Squad:
quote:Originally posted by Route C:
quote:Originally posted by boutrous11:
well, last year i got stuck with 2 crappy kickers and 2 crappy defenses. and i had to pay too much for them, as there were several of us scrambling to get them at the end of the draft. wasn't going to let that happen again. :D That's an excellent point. The better prices are usually toward the middle of the draft. [/QUOTE]Prediction - No DEF under $4
[/QUOTE]Is this your sinister way to get someone to actually pay $4 for Detroit's defense????

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:03 am
by bobsgym13
Originally posted by bald is beautiful:
quote:Originally posted by Bob Squad:
quote:Originally posted by Route C:
quote:Originally posted by boutrous11:
well, last year i got stuck with 2 crappy kickers and 2 crappy defenses. and i had to pay too much for them, as there were several of us scrambling to get them at the end of the draft. wasn't going to let that happen again. :D That's an excellent point. The better prices are usually toward the middle of the draft. [/QUOTE]Prediction - No DEF under $4
[/QUOTE]Is this your sinister way to get someone to actually pay $4 for Detroit's defense????
[/QUOTE]Have you seen their schedule? Awesome!!!

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:25 am
by boutrous11
I had to pay 4 bucks for SF last year. :(

[ February 23, 2009, 05:26 PM: Message edited by: boutrous11 ]

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2009 2:01 am
by bobsgym13
Jeff,

More analysis

2007 Top Three DEF's (and their 2008 rankings)

1 SD (18)
2 NE (17)
3 SEA (22)

[ February 26, 2009, 08:45 AM: Message edited by: Bob Squad ]

Slow auction evaluations

Posted: Thu Feb 26, 2009 4:20 am
by Route Collectors
Originally posted by Bob Squad:
Jeff,

More analysis

2007 Top Three DEF's (and their 2008 rankings)

1 SD (18)
2 NE (17)
3 SEA (22) All very valid points along with the Balt/Philly stats you provided on the other thread.

I would lay $$$ out though that SF comes nowhere close to the success that Balt and Philly enjoyed last season.

Anyway it's still fun bustin your chops. I can't wait to hang out again in Chi-town. :D