Greg Jennings vs. Roddy White

[BillyWaz]

Originally posted by GK:
quote:Originally posted by BillyWaz:
quote:Originally posted by GK:
quote:Originally posted by BillyWaz:
quote:Originally posted by Coltsfan:
Glenn,

I have Jennings over White but it's obviously close. The WR I'm struggling with is Boldin. Where does he fit in?


Wayne Wayne,

I've got Boldin behind both of those guys, and a couple other guys as well.

Boldin is AWESOME when he plays, but you can't expect more than 14 games out of him. If MarShawyn Lynch is currently suspended for 3 games and is going in the 4th or 5th round, why is someone you KNOW who will miss at least 2 games going in the 2nd???

I guess it is his PPG (which admittedly is spectacular) or the fact that people are holding out for that this is the year he stays healthy.

As for the question, Jennings over Roddy. [/QUOTE]...Boldin got hurt on a FREAK play against the Jets which would have put any other ordinary competitor out more games than Q missed...the kat is not only talented but tougher than most people/owners give him credit for...look for Boldin to be out to prove to the Cards and the rest of the league that he not only wants to but must be paid what he's worth by if not the Cardinals then certainly by some team out there...SNAKE [/QUOTE]I agree that hit was nasty, and almost every other WR in the league would have been done for MUCH longer.

The problem is although this cat is as tough as they come, one man can only take so much abuse!

Here is where we were at the END of the season....

He missed two more (albeit meaningless) games in Weeks 16 and 17 due to a shoulder.

Then he pulled up with a lame hamstring on his score against Atlanta in the playoffs, did not return, and DID NOT play in the playoff game against Carolina.

He was used minimally against Philly the following week (4-34) and really needed those two weeks between the Super Bowl.

Don't get me wrong, Anquan is a BEAST, I just think there are equal, safer options in his "neighborhood". [/QUOTE]...oh yeah?...like who Billyboy?...Jennings and White?...SNAKE [/QUOTE]Do you actually read, or do you just see my posts and find ANYTHING to argue with??? :rolleyes:

Jennings AND Roddy are in a tier ABOVE Anquan in my book.

[BillyWaz]

Originally posted by Coltsfan:
Billy,

I don't believe that Lynch and Boldin are a fair comparison. Boldin isn't guaranteed to miss 3 weeks. Plus, my fear with Lynch is a Fred Jackson time share this year. So for me they are completely different situations.

Let's say Boldin hit his per game average from last year of 21 points and played 13 games. In the other weeks you play a WW player that avg's 8 points per game. That is still 297 points which is more than I project for either White or Jennings. Any thoughts?

That is very true Wayne, and after I posted that I too realized the comparison was unfair.

Last year Anquan was "off the charts", and I simply don't see the 21 ppg happening again. Bump it down to 18, with your same criteria, and we are talking 258.

Still not bad, I think there are just safer guys, and the "stigma" of being a #2 (knowing he isn't the true #1 option in the passing game) make it hard for me to pull the trigger over clear #1's on their team......

Like Greg Jennings and Roddy White!

Wayne

[pizzatyme]

Jennings


Boldin


White

[davidd23]

RODDY WHITE

JENNINGS

BOLDIN

thats the way i see it right now , as much as i love boldin , tough to put him ahead of the other 2 who are the undisputed top targets on their teams. also , as great as warner was last year , i love the young stud qb's that jennings and white play with. warner gets hurt and who knows how good leinart will be?
then again , a healthy boldin could out perform fitz , not likely but very possible.
many times in fantasy the last 10 years has a nfl team had 2 super wr's , the guy getting picked first in most drafts has been out performed by the "second" guy.
great debate here with 3 very talented wr's

[trueblue]

i currently have them
jennings
white
boldin
and wouldn't feel bad with any of them.

[Raiders]

Originally posted by kentuckyreign:
i currently have them
jennings
white
boldin
and wouldn't feel bad with any of them. Interesting because Just Russ has it
Boldin,White,Jennings.

Missed out on this Topic, nice job Snake. Keep these coming. I don't have these 3 guys as close as must do.

John

[trueblue]

Originally posted by Raiders:
quote:Originally posted by kentuckyreign:
i currently have them
jennings
white
boldin
and wouldn't feel bad with any of them. Interesting because Just Russ has it
Boldin,White,Jennings.

Missed out on this Topic, nice job Snake. Keep these coming. I don't have these 3 guys as close as must do.

John [/QUOTE]i think russ posted

jennings
boldin
white

at least we agree on one of them..BTW, have them very close to each other.

bill

[Raiders]

Originally posted by kentuckyreign:
quote:Originally posted by Raiders:
quote:Originally posted by kentuckyreign:
i currently have them
jennings
white
boldin
and wouldn't feel bad with any of them. Interesting because Just Russ has it
Boldin,White,Jennings.

Missed out on this Topic, nice job Snake. Keep these coming. I don't have these 3 guys as close as must do.

John [/QUOTE]i think russ posted

jennings
boldin
white

at least we agree on one of them..BTW, have them very close to each other.

bill [/QUOTE]

[GOD Loves You]

Originally posted by Just Russ:
Jennings


Boldin


White Boldin
v
Jennings
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
White