Critique my recent Slow DC draft please.

pizzatyme · Post by **pizzatyme** » Sat Jun 13, 2009 11:10 am

I figured I'd toss this out for everyone to get a laugh. To show your appreciation, maybe you can tell me where I went right or wrong in your eyes.

Thanks in advance...

round lastname firstname
1 Peterson Adrian
2 Bowe Dwayne
3 Moreno Knowshon
4 Gates Antonio
5 Holmes Santonio
6 Palmer Carson
7 Taylor Chester
8 Edwards Trent
9 Crabtree Michael
10 Bradshaw Ahmad
11 Buckhalter Correll
12 Nicks Hakeem
13 Indianapolis Colts
14 Seattle Seahawks
15 Choice Tashard
16 Jones Matt
17 Bruce Isaac
18 Vinatieri Adam
19 Walker Mike
20 Feely Jay
21 Heap Todd
22 Burton Keenan
23 Ware Danny
24 Simms Chris
25 Stroughter Sammie
26 Robinson Gijon
27 Jackson Tarvaris
28 Martin David
29 Sorgi Jim
30 Ringer Javon
31 Tamme Jacob
32 Kelly Malcolm

Enjoy and critique away!

pizzatyme · Post by **pizzatyme** » Sat Jun 13, 2009 12:35 pm

Here is the team by position:

QBs
Palmer Carson
Edwards Trent
Simms Chris
Jackson Tarvaris
Sorgi Jim

RBs
Peterson Adrian
Moreno Knowshon
Taylor Chester
Bradshaw Ahmad
Buckhalter Correll
Choice Tashard
Ware Danny
Ringer Javon

WRs
Bowe Dwayne
Holmes Santonio
Crabtree Michael
Nicks Hakeem
Jones Matt
Bruce Isaac
Walker Mike
Burton Keenan
Stroughter Sammie
Kelly Malcolm

TEs
Gates Antonio
Heap Todd
Robinson Gijon
Martin David
Tamme Jacob

D/STs
Indianapolis Colts
Seattle Seahawks

Ks
Vinatieri Adam
Feely Jay

pizzatyme · Post by **pizzatyme** » Sat Jun 13, 2009 3:17 pm

Originally posted by GK:
...Comrade Russ - do you want a SNAKE assessment (which you KNOW is equal to an always honest one) or not?...thanks much...SNAKE I have no ego about these drafts. Tell like you see it.

trueblue · Post by **trueblue** » Sat Jun 13, 2009 6:38 pm

i'll bite, same draft

QB
tbrady
cpennington
jfreeman
mgutierrez

RB
mlynch
lwhite
dbrown
lmccoy
mmorris
drhodes
gcoffee

WR
ajohnson
mcolston
vjax
mjenkins
nwashington
djarrett
hdouglas
bstokley
bsmith
aarrington
sjohnson
jcribbs

TE
dkeller
hmiller
sheiden
drosario

K
sgostkowski
ssuisam

D/ST
carolina
san francisco
detroit

Coltsfan · Post by **Coltsfan** » Sun Jun 14, 2009 2:39 am

Russ,

I don't understand why you ignored WR for so long. The problem I see is that you won't put up enough points at WR to compete. You have a lot of upside RB's but even if they hit you will need a lot of luck from rookie WR's or Matt Jones finding a team to be a factor. I don't see a lot of upside with some of your late round picks. I would rather pickup a low level WR3 or an upside WR4 than Sorgi at QB5.

On the positive side it seems like you nailed the first 6 rounds. I don't like to backup my RB in the first 7 - especially in a winner take all DC. (Two roster spots for one position typically equals a great chance at being middle of the pack.) If you added in a Donal Driver or Torry Holt in the 7th your team starts to look much better. Also, I believe the benefit from 3 Def's can be powerful.

I guess when I look at the team there are just too many players that very well could not be seeing much of the field this year. It would be nice to have more everydown players that will consistently give you something. Just my 2 cents which you probably know would be overpaying for my advice.

Wayne

Coltsfan · Post by **Coltsfan** » Sun Jun 14, 2009 2:41 am

Originally posted by kentuckyreign:
i'll bite, same draft

QB
tbrady
cpennington
jfreeman
mgutierrez

RB
mlynch
lwhite
dbrown
lmccoy
mmorris
drhodes
gcoffee

WR
ajohnson
mcolston
vjax
mjenkins
nwashington
djarrett
hdouglas
bstokley
bsmith
aarrington
sjohnson
jcribbs

TE
dkeller
hmiller
sheiden
drosario

K
sgostkowski
ssuisam

D/ST
carolina
san francisco
detroit Bill,

Lots of upside at RB and if they hit then you can definitely compete with this team. I absolutely love your late round picks - well done.

Wayne

boutrous11 · Post by **boutrous11** » Sun Jun 14, 2009 3:07 am

here's mine:

didn't like the 5 hole at first, but i guess it wasn't terrible.

Brees
Culpepper
Stafford
Hanie
Batch

S. Jackson
Wells
Hightower
L. McClain
A. Pittman
K. Darby
P. Hillis
M. Hart

Housh
Gonzales
Coles
Breaston
Hixon
Branch
Dem. Williams
Laur. Robison
A. Caldwell
Lagadu

J. Carlson
M. Lewis
S. Nelson

Folk
Mare
Coutu

Carolina, Jax, Detroit

pizzatyme · Post by **pizzatyme** » Sun Jun 14, 2009 3:29 am

Originally posted by GK:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Just Russ:
[qb]
RB: you more than likely have the best there is at the position and backed him up - well done!...you dittoed that with your RB2 as well (who will be alright this season but will NOT outperform his ADP ISHO)...the only problem is that SNAKE is NOT a big fan of either Denver RB this year - sorry...Bradshaw just might indeed be your saving grace at the position IF his workload is similiar to that of Derrick Ward's last season...after that SNAKE likes not...Overall Grade: C

Glenn, thanks for the feedback. One question about the RB grade, if you think I have the #1RB overall and his handcuff, plus Moreno and his cuff, how does this get a C? Do you not think that is enough to compete at the RB level with the balance of the league?